Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1350550
maltatoday | SUNDAY • 14 MARCH 2021 15 THE granting of citizenship is the Minister's discretion and therefore, cannot be subject to the Court's judicial review. This was held by the First Hall of the Civil Court, presided by Mr Jus- tice Robert Mangion in Ena Sho- by Zaky Ibrahim Attia -v- Diret- tur tac-Cittadinanza, Ministru ghall-Gustizzja, Kultura u Gvern Lokali. The Plaintiff filed a sworn appli- cation asking the court to over- turn a decision of the Director of the Citizenship which did not accept her application to become a Maltese citizen. There was no reason given to the decision taken in March 2017. The government replied stating that Article 469A of the Code of Organisation and Civil Procedure does not apply, which the granting of citizenship is the prerogative of the State and is not administrative act. The Director held that she should not be part of this case be- cause it is the Minister who grants citizenship and not the Director. Mr Justice Mangion analysed the evidence brought forward the Court. The Plaintiff applied for citizenship in August 2010 and received the decision over 7 years later. She filed a judicial protest against the Defendants holding them responsible for their actions and claiming that the rules of nat- ural justice was not followed in the procedure. Her lawyer explained to the Court on how she applied filled in the necessary forms in terms of Article 10(1) of the Maltese Citizenship Act in August 2010. Officials of Identity Malta also testified and explained that there are two methods of becoming Maltese citizens, either by one's ancestry or else by naturalisation, based on being a resident in Mal- ta. The authority does not depend on its applicants documents but has an independent due diligence. It was revealed that an official was being paid to process this applica- tion and there were newspaper ar- ticles of criminal judgements the plaintiff was subject of. There is also a contestation on the paterni- ty of the children, which Identity Malta, took seriously. Further- more, the marriage certificate does not contain any information on her separation. The Plaintiff testified and ex- plained that she came to Malta in 2003 on a holiday, where she met her husband. She returned to Egypt, but their relationship con- tinued until she returned and both got married. The marriage was an unhappy one and at one point she had to take refuge at a shelter. She complained that her citizen- ship application took 7 years and not reason was given why it was turned down. She had met the then Minister Tonio Borg, who pointed out that she was not resi- dent in Malta for 10 years, but he would keep her file pending until 2013. When she went to the Min- istry again, there was a change of administration. The file was left pending a second time because of her paternity case. Then the deci- sion was communicated that her application was turned down. As to whether the Director of Citizenship was correctly suited, the Court referred to the Maltese Citizenship Act, which gives the power of accepting new citizens to the Minister responsible for citizenship or to other author- ised persons. There is no evidence showing that any other person is authorised to act in the name of the Minister. Furthermore, ac- cording to Article 19 of the Act held that no reason needs to be given by the Minister for his de- cision. Therefore, the Minister is the deciding authority. The Court then ruled that the Direc- tor should not be part of these proceedings. As to the Minister of Justice, Culture and Local Government, the decision was given in March 2017 and the action was institut- ed in June 2017. The Minister re- sponsible for citizenship was the Minister of Justice, Culture and Local Government. Parliament was dissolved on 1 May 2017 and after the general elections on 4 June 2017 the new ministries were assigned on 10 and 13 June 2017, after the case was filed. Therefore, the case was correctly filed against the correct ministry. As to the merits of the case the actions is asking for a judicial re- view of an administrative deci- sion. Article 469A of the COCP states that a judicial review can take place on whether the admin- istrative act was ultra vires and the authority did not observe the principles of natural justice. The Defendants argued that citizen- ship is at the discretion of the State and it is also secret, since it could involve national security. As such the State is not legally bound to explain why citizenship applications are refused. Black- stone defines prerogative as "ex- ceptional powers, preeminences and privileges which the law gives the government. That special preeminence which the govern- ment has over and above all other persons in right of regal dignity.' The prerogative of giving citizen- ship is exclusively in the hands of the minister. This was also accepted by the European Union Court of Justice in documents en- titled "Pathways to citizenship for third country nationals in the EU Member States", published on 5 August 2019. Every member state must take into consideration the laws of the European Union when giving citizenship and this is be- cause once a citizen of a member state, that person will be also a cit- izen of the European Union. The Minister is not bound to give an explanation in terms of Article 19 of the Maltese Citi- zenship Act, which is derived from Article 44(2) of the British Nationality Act 1981 and its pre- decessor British Nationality Act 1948. The Court then moved to up- hold the pleas and turn down the Plaintiff's claims. LAW CLASSIFIEDS CLASSIFIEDS INFO @MEDIATODAY.COM.MT There is no judicial review for decisions refusing citizenship applications HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION MARSALFORN, Gozo - holiday apart- ments for short or long lets with mag- nificent sea-views. Call 21556021, 27556021, 79426883 PROPERTY TO LET XLENDI - catering premises in prime site to let. Can be used for other com- mercial purposes. Phone 79493021, 79426883, 77481592 or 77484029 PROPERTY FOR SALE QAWRA – Calling all developers this is an ideal development opportunity. Presently a 3 bedroomed penthouse with own airspace on the outskirts of Qawra close to Kennedy Grove, not far from the new primary school and main bus routes. Two double bedrooms and 1 single bedroom, two bathrooms, lift, double glazing doors and windows. With the option to build up a further 3 floors. Offers in the region of €310k. Once devel- oped these apartments would be a strategic rental investment or resale opportunity. Kindly message owner on 99201846. NO AGENTS. SAN GWANN- Open plan 190sqm, ready to move into designer fin- ished second floor apartment in a central quiet street forming part of a block of 5 apartments. Two double A/C bedrooms and 1 single A/C bedroom, two bathrooms, lift, double glazing doors and windows. Direct from owner €350k inquire on 79402244. TARXIEN - Larger than usual first floor duplex maisonette. Three bed- rooms; double glazed windows; invert- er air conditioners including solar water heater. Being sold furnished. Own airspace with possibility of fur- ther development. Contact owner on 99912005/99450639. SERVICES NEWSPAPER adverts - Book & pay on-line on www.perfecta.com.mt - no extra charges. Call on 21322452 SITUATIONS VACANT EXTRUDER & COILING MACHINE OPERATOR - required for the Low Voltage Electrical Cables - Experience Required - Knowledge of Arabic and English Speaking is an asset, please sent you CV to accounts@smcables.com or call +356 21697888. JUNIOR OFFICE CLERK - a vacancy has arisen at a shipping company locat- ed in Marsa. Following requirements are O Level standard passes, comput- er literate – Microsoft office, knowl- edge of Maltese and English languages. Ability to communicate and work on own initiative / 'hands-on' approach. Prospective candidates can send cv on email: vvella@valfreightmalta.com SPA THERAPIST - Required for a bou- tique hotel. Full time hours including weekends and public holidays. Must be flexible with hours. At least 5 years' expe- rience in a similar post. Must be special- ised in colonic irrigation. For more info please call Village Concept on 99885352. VASSALLO & XUEREB LTD – located in Mriehel, Birkirkara we are looking for: Blacksmiths, Blacksmith Apprentices, Blasters, Sprayers, Welders, Electricians, Tile Layers, Construction Foremans, Foremans, Painters, Plumbers, Gypsum Installers, Labourers. Interesting Candidates must have a minimum of 3/5 years of working experience, must work shifts day and night and flexible working hours. Please kindly send us your CV and covering letter at info@ vassalloandsons.com WANTED COLLECTIBLE items such panini albums and loose stickers, old postcards and posted envelopes, medals, militar- ia, coins and paper money, books, toys, stamps, badges, paintings, gold & silver items etc. Call on 21310238, 99246632. LAW REPORT MALCOLM MIFSUD Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates