MaltaToday previous editions

MALTATODAY 19 December 2021

Issue link:

Contents of this Issue


Page 17 of 51

2 maltatoday EXECUTIVE EDITOR Matthew Vella Letters to the Editor, MaltaToday, Vjal ir-Rihan, San Gwann SGN 9016 E-mail: Letters must be concise, no pen names accepted, include full name and address maltatoday | SUNDAY • 19 DECEMBER 2021 Abela's elastic ethical yardstick Editorial ROBERT Abela's decision to postpone the fate of ed- ucation minister Justyne Caruana until the standards committee discusses the Hyzler report, is weak lead- ership in the face of a clear-cut case of impropriety. For a leader basking in popularity and leading the Opposition by such a wide margin, his incapability to send a strong message of moral renewal is especially needed now needed considering the pits to which the country fell under his predecessor. Abela still sends mixed messages on whether he represents continuity or change. What is most striking in this case is that Abela is hesitant to act on a case where Caruana's removal is watertight: a direct order awarded to a minister's friend for what looks like a phantom job, with the connivance of civil servants who were duty-bound to stop this from happening. The Standards Commissioner not only found Daniel Bogdanovic unsuitable for the €15,000 task assigned to him, but that the sports curriculum re- port he had to author was actually compiled by Paul Debattista, a consultant to the minister. Bogdanovic's contribution was minimal and mostly carried out on instructions from Debattista. Abela is playing for time to avoid upsetting the ap- ple cart by having to reshuffle the Cabinet for a new education minister, right before the general election; apart from curating the ministerial balance in the Gozitan constituency. Or is he is expecting Caruana to step down so as to avoid spilling blood? Is Abela more interested in party unity than in the national interest? More worrying is the way Abela revised his ethical yardstick, starting his term with a strong message of accountability by kicking Konrad Mizzi out, only to become more cautious as time went by. In 2020 Caruana herself had to resign from Gozo minister af- ter it was revealed her husband, former deputy police commissioner Silvio Valletta, had a close friendship with Daphne Caruana Galizia murder suspect Yorgen Fenech. In many cases – Konrad Mizzi, Chris Cardo- na... – Abela acted without waiting for the conclusion of any investigation. This changed when MaltaToday broke the news about Rosianne Cutajar's role as a broker on property deal linked to Yorgen Fenech. There Abela awaited for all the facts to be established by Standards Com- missioner George Hyzler. By March, further reve- lations of Fenech's €9,000 gift to Cutajar saw Abela "accepting" her 'temporary' resignation before the publication of the Standards report. When the report concluded that the junior minister had breached ethics, Cutajar was simply not reappointed. But in the case of Caruana, the Standards verdict has been delivered. Now it is up to MPs to discuss the report, endorse it and recommend sanctions against Caruana. Neither government nor opposition mem- bers can add anything to the facts established by the investigation itself. So Abela is either waiting for Cutajar to take her down decision in the New Year, or he intends push- ing Labour MPs on the standards committee to possi- bly exonerate Cutajar in tandem with the Speaker. It looks like an unlikely prospect for someone as savvy as Abela to risk so much for the fate of a minister who is not even being defended by party media or the usual army of sycophants. But Abela's difficulties are compounded by his go- slow justification: no interim measures for Caruana (as he did with Cutajar) because "the difference be- tween this case and Rosianne Cutajar's is that Cuta- jar's case involved Yorgen Fenech." So now Abela has added a nebulous yard stick in which association with Fenech counts as an aggra- vating factor in assessing misconduct. Then why was Cutajar retained as MP and on the Labour ticket? Why had this not been an immediate consideration in December 2020 when the buck was passed on to the Standards czar? Indeed, Cutajar's proximity to Fenech was not even a problem for Labour: Abela said it was the receipt of any money that could be a problem. One year later, Abela now says it is Cutajar's associ- ation with Fenech that cost her her position. So how does this inpact the fate of other Cabinet members like Edward Zammit Lewis who remained in contact with Fenech even after he was exposed as the owner of 17 Black? Abela has inadvertently raised the stake for Labour politicians who were close to Fenech, a part-owned of Malta's gas plant. While association with the magnate is problematic in the same manner as the Italians might treat association with the mafia, this is no alibi for impropiety when it happens to be unliked to the Caruana Galizia murder. After Abela downplayed the gravity of being as- sociated with Yorgen Fenech, this cannot be used selectively to buy time for a Prime Minister who is not keen on cleaning out – once again – the Cabinet stables. 18 December 2011 Hundreds march in Valletta in call for decriminalisation of cannabis AROUND 300 people this morning marched through the streets of Valletta calling for the liberalisation and decriminalisation of can- nabis. As passers-by expressed shock at the dem- onstrators' call, the activists went on unaf- fected, carrying placards reading 'Please tax me', 'Legal Cannabis = Bankrupt drug cartels', 'Dealers don't check for ID's – Protect Kids Legalise Marijuana' and 'God made marijua- na - man made pharmaceutical: who do you trust?' The activists also handed out informational leaflet on cannabis to people in Valletta. Upon reaching the Law Courts, the demon- strators started chanting, "we are not crimi- nals" and "legalise it". Addressing the crowd in St George's Square, organiser David Caruana thanked the mem- bers of the Police Force "for their patience and protection, who without them the activity could not be held". Meanwhile at the beginning and during the peaceful demonstration, police officers taking down notes on what was written on the vari- ous placards. Caruana said they were calling for an urgent and much needed reform, which is already 10 years late. "Not only to decriminalise drugs, but as both political parties said this week, a reform is also needed for the classification of drugs. Legalising and regulating cannabis would place government in charge of it, taking it away from the criminals and out of the hands of children." Caruana added such regulation goes hand- in-hand with the right of an adult individual to have control over his mind and body. He went on to mention the benefits of cannabis as a medicinal and for therapeutic needs. "The criminal act is not smoking a joint, but denying a sick person from the help it gives; the criminal act lies in prohibiting the con- sumption of a plant which prevents several types of cancer," Caruana said. ... Quote of the Week "The head of state cannot capriciously create a constitutional crisis and cause instability… there is nothing in our Constitution that gives the president the final say on a law" President George Vella in a message directed towards the different voices opposed to the cannabis reform bill, calling on him not to sign the legislation MaltaToday 10 years ago

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of MaltaToday previous editions - MALTATODAY 19 December 2021