Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1478813
maltatoday | SUNDAY • 11 SEPTEMBER 2022 15 LAW CLASSIFIEDS THE fact that the contracting au- thority did not follow anti com- petition recommendations does not mean that the tender should be cancelled. This was held by the Court of Appeal, presided by the Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti and Judges Giannino Caruana Demajo and Anthony Ellul on 6 September 2022. The case's name is Vivian Corporation Limited -v- Central Procurement and Sup- plies Unit et The appeal was lodged by Vivi- an Corporation Limited following a decision of the Public Contracts Review Board. The Board reject- ed a request for a tender to be withdrawn by the Central Pro- curement and Supplies United (CPSU) for the purchase of "ready made feeds for preterm and new- born babies". The only criteria was based on the cheapest price. Vivian Corporation claimed that only one supplier may win this tender. The Review Board did not agree that the tender should be cancelled. The decision referred to a report issued by the Malta Competition and Consumer Af- fairs Authority (MCCAA) which sought that tenders should "bet- ter its procurement process for the well-functioning of the sec- ondary markets…." The Court of Appeal went in- to the Board's decision. The Board held that a tender may be cancelled by the Director of Contracts or by the contracting authority within specific param- eters outlined in Article 90(3) of the Public Procurement Regula- tions. Vivian Corporation argued that the CPSU did not follow the norms of the Court of Appeal, which held that it should follow the recommendation of the Di- rector General (Competition) of the possible anti-competition consequences when it choses a tenderer. The Appellant Compa- ny held that this tender distorts competition on the market. The report presents recommenda- tions on alternative procurement practices which are intended to remove any negative impact in the market. The CPSU argued that this is- sued was already decided No- vember 2020 and had rejected the claims. The Court of Appeal also dealt with the same issues was decided against the Appellant Company on 17 March 2021. The other parties to this case also filed statement of defence. MCCAA argued that the Office for Com- petition conducted an inquiry in terms of the Competition Act with regard to infant milk formula and the tendering process at Ma- ter Dei Hospital. It recommended that the CPSU should change its public procurement practices to avoid harming competition. The Court of Appeal 2021 judgement explained that market dominance is not illegal, but the abuse of that dominance is illegal. If a dominant player in the mar- ket manipulates the prices, this would be contrary to law. The Board took into account the report and the Court of Ap- peal judgement and found that the contracting authority could proceed with the tender as is. The Appellant Company, Viv- ian Corporation held that the circumstances are now different from the 2021 judgement, as the contracting party is asking for the cheapest price. This meant only one supplier would qualify. This would bring an unfair advantage as mothers would continue to use the same product that would be given to them in hospital. The Appellant Company wanted that the tender allow multiple brands. The Court of Appeal failed to see where there was a change of cir- cumstances to the previous case. The Court of Appeal held that the law does not give the discre- tion to the Review Board cancel a tender for whatever reason, but it may cancel a tender when there are irregularities in the ten- dering process. If no irregular- ity is shown the Board and the Court cannot by law cancel the tender. The Appellant Company held that there was no breach of the law, but the appeal concerns that the contracting authority did not follow the recommenda- tion outlined in the report. The question is whether the fact that the recommendations were fol- lowed amounts to an irregulari- ty. The Malta Competition and Consumer Affairs Authority Act allows the authority to give advice to public authorities in carryout their duties. However, these rec- ommendations are not binding. The Court of Appeal is not al- lowed to carry out an investiga- tion but it is to decide on public procurement. The Court cannot substitute its authority with that of the contracting party. The Court of Appeal also looked at the current Maltese legisla- tion and the European Directive 2014/24/UE and although it is desirable that the tendering pro- cess does not effect negatively the competition rules, it does not mean that a tender should be can- celled. The fact that the contracting authority is insisting to go ahead with the tender process does not mean that its intention is to dis- tort the market. The Appellant Company did file a bid in order to win that bid. It gave a perfor- mance guarantee. If it were cho- sen then it would not refuse to sign the contract because of an- ti-competition considerations. As such the Court held that it did not find serious enough irreg- ulatorities to justify the cancella- tion of the tender. The Court then moved to reject the appeal. For a tender to be cancelled serious irreg ularities must be proven LAW REPORT MALCOLM MIFSUD Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION MARSALFORN, Gozo - holiday apart- ments for short or long lets with magnif- icent sea-views. Call 21556021, 27556021, 79426883 PROPERTY TO LET XLENDI - catering premises in prime site to let. Can be used for other commer- cial purposes. Phone 79493021, 79426883, 77481592 or 77484029 PROPERTY FOR SALE SAN GWANN- Open plan 190sqm, ready to move into designer finished second floor apartment in a central quiet street forming part of a block of 5 apartments. Two double A/C bedrooms and 1 single A/C bedroom, two bathrooms, lift, double glazing doors and windows. Direct from owner €350k inquire on 79402244. TARXIEN - Larger than usual first floor duplex maisonette. Three bedrooms; dou- ble glazed windows; inverter air condition- ers including solar water heater. Being sold furnished. Own airspace with possibility of further development. Contact owner on 99912005/99450639. SERVICES COLLECTIBLE items such panini albums and loose stickers, old postcards and post- ed envelopes, medals, militaria, coins and paper money, books, toys, stamps, badges, paintings, gold & silver items etc. Call on 21310238, 99246632. SITUATIONS VACANT AJ ENTERPRISES LTD - We are seek- ing the services of Labourers on a full- time basis. Applicants must be Maltese & English speaking and have a minimum of 1 year experience in Aluminium & PVC works. Apply by sending an email with your CV to info@ajenterprises.eu CASHIER - DoodlePi Ltd is looking to employ a Cashier for an Asian Mini Market on a full-time basis. The applicant must be fluent in English and Mandarin. Interested persons are invited to send their CV via email to qipeng99023536@gmail. com by not later than 15th September 2022. No agencies please. KITCHEN HAND - The operators of The Edge Take Away Qormi are seeking to employ one KITCHEN HAND. The ideal candidate must be in possession of a Food Handling Certificate and must be a fluent English speaker. The duties include taking instructions from the Chef, preparation of food (washing, peeling, chopping, etc), cleaning the kitchen both in advance of cooking and also afterwards. Ideal can- didate may also be assigned other duties. Salary offered: 900 Euro per month. Email cv to bartolostephen@hotmail.com by not later than 11th September 2022. 7 DAYS LTD – vacancies have arisen for a Sushi Chef / Asian Food Chef / kitchen helper / waiter/waitress. Call on 27811888 for further information. EXPERIENCED WAITER - required for busy hotel restaurant in Naxxar. Must be fluent in English, be able to work flexible hours including weekends and public hol- idays. Min 2 years' experience in similar position. Call +35627988357 for more info - The Village Hotel LTD. GRIXTI PROPERTIES LTD - has job positions for General labourers & General Construction Cleaners in roads construc- tion. Applicants must have experience, flu- ently speak English and other languages. Hourly rate Eur4.50. Interested applicants may send e-mail to: secretary@a-plus- plus.eu IBESEEN MALTA Ltd - has vacancies for waiters, cleaners and helpers in offic- es, hotels, hostels, guest houses and other establishments, Security Officers, Truck Drivers, Glass Blowers, Agricultural Labourers and for Construction Labourers & General Construction Cleaners in road works. Applicants must have minimum of two / three years' experience. Fluently speaking English and other languag- es. Hourly rate from Eur4.62 / Eur5.50. Interested applicants may send email to secretary@a-plusplus.eu JEWEL RECRUITMENT Ltd - has vacan- cies for waiters, cleaners and helpers in offices, hotels, hostels, guest houses and other establishments, for Security Officers, Glass Blowers, Agricultural Labourers and for Construction Labourers & General Construction Cleaners in road works. Applicants must have minimum of two / three years' experience. Fluently speaking English and other languages. Hourly rate from Eur4.62 / Eur5.50. Interested appli- cants may send email to secretary@a-plus- plus.eu CLASSIFIEDS INFO @MEDIATODAY.COM.MT