Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1497281
maltatoday | SUNDAY • 16 APRIL 2023 11 LAW CLASSIFIEDS A consignee is considered to be a legitimate respondent in intellectual property pro- ceedings. This was outlined in LVMH Fragrance Brands vs Globtainer Logistique Algerie SARL decided by the Court of Appeal (Superior Jurisdiction) on 16th March 2023. President Gianino Caruana Demajo, Judge Tonio Mallia and Judge Anthony Ellul presided over the case. By means of a court applica- tion, the plaintiff company de- clared that 23,436 aerosol cans which were being held by the Customs Authority in Malta following its decision to sus- pend the release of a contain- er, contravene its intellectual property's rights in relation to its trademarks registered in Malta. It alleged that the products were not genuine and original, and requested that the Customs Authority dispose of the said products at the ex- pense of the defendant compa- ny, which was the consignee of the shipment. In its sworn reply, the re- spondent stated that it was not to be considered as the legiti- mate respondent in the action because it only acted as a cor- respondent in Algeria of the non-vessel owning common Turkish carrier Anko Anadolu Konteyner, and was simply an intermediary. The importer of the shipment was EURL Merd- hia Packaging which is listed as the notified party in the waybill presented by the plaintiff. In its decision, the First Hall Civil Court stated that a con- signee is a person to whom the merchandise is sent to and who secures the release of such cargo, while a notify party is a person who is notified that the merchandise has arrived but has no title over it. Since the defendants failed to contact the importer EURL Merdhia Pack- aging to become a joinder of the proceedings to respond to the allegations, the Court up- held the plaintiff's claims and ordered the defendant compa- ny to pay the expenses. The defendant company de- cided to appeal the judgement given by the First Hall, Civ- il Court on the grounds that it wrongfully interpreted the law and the evidence submit- ted by it. It said that it was not the consignee of this shipment and presented a copy of the Bill of Lading which indicated Aryumn Metal Tup Imalat San Dis Tic A.S. as the shipper and EURL Merdhia Packaging as the consignee. They presented an affidavit whereby Mr Nait Ibrahim Hassane declared that Globtainer Logistique Algerie SARL was listed as the consign- ee to permit it to collect the de- livery orders from CMA CGM at the port of discharge, and that Anko Anodolu Container SA gave them instructions to mention Globtainer Logistique Algerie SARL as the consign- ee on the transport document. Therefore, they were not to be held responsible for the ex- penses to dispose of the cargo. The Court of Appeal exam- ined the documents and said that whilst the sea waybill iden- tifies Globtainer Logistique Al- gerie SARL as the consignee, the insurance certificate shows EURL Merdhia Packaging as the consignee. An invoice also indicated EURL Merdhia Pack- aging as the importer of goods. Article 4 of the Intellectual Property Rights (Cross-Bor- der Measures) Act states that the entry into Malta, export or re-export, release for free cir- culation, temporary importa- tion, placing in a free zone or free warehouse of goods found to be goods infringing an intel- lectual property right shall be prohibited. The Court outlined that since the defendant is listed as a consignee on the waybill, it forms part of those persons in- volved in any of the operations outlined in Article 4. There- fore, the Customs Authority is obliged to give their name and address to the intellectual property rights' holder to be able to institute proceedings in Court, where necessary. The Court quoted Arti- cle 2(14) of EU Regulation 608/2013 on Customs Enforce- ment of Intellectual Property Rights which states that the 'object holder' is that person who has the physical control over the objects, in this case, the defendant company. There- fore, it decided that Globtainer Logistique Algerie SARL was deemed to be a legitimate re- spondent in the proceedings and confirmed this part of the judgement given by the First Hall Civil Court. Nevertheless, The Court re- formed the part of the judge- ment whereby the defendant company was ordered to pay for the expenses to dispose of the goods. It outlined that according to Article 8 of the Intellectual Property Rights (Cross-Border Measures) Act, it is the importer, exporter or the owner of the goods which must pay such expenses. A consignee is considered to be a legitimate respondent in intellectual property proceedings LAW REPORT MALCOLM MIFSUD Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates CLASSIFIEDS INFO @MEDIATODAY.COM.MT HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION MARSALFORN, Gozo - holiday apart- ments for short or long lets with mag- nificent sea-views. Call 21556021, 27556021, 79426883 PROPERTY TO LET SHOP TO LEASE - Class 4 B 60 sqm corner shop to lease in San Gwann. Key money €49,888 and €40 a day rental. Call on 79703404. XLENDI - catering premises in prime site to let. Can be used for other com- mercial purposes. Phone 79493021, 79426883, 77481592 or 77484029 PROPERTY FOR SALE SAN GWANN- Open plan 190sqm, ready to move into designer finished second floor apartment in a central quiet street forming part of a block of 5 apartments. Two double A/C bed- rooms and 1 single A/C bedroom, two bathrooms, lift, double glazing doors and windows. Direct from owner €350k inquire on 79402244. SERVICES COLLECTIBLE items such panini albums and loose stickers, old post- cards and posted envelopes, medals, militaria, coins and paper money, books, toys, stamps, badges, paint- ings, gold & silver items etc. Call on 21310238, 99246632. SITUATIONS VACANT ADMINISTRATION EXECUTIVE - Oasis Operations Ltd are seeking for bus drivers. Kindly send your CV on philip@oasistoursmalta.com CLEANER/HELPER - Torri Gardens Ltd, Lija requires a cleaner/helper on a full-time basis. The ideal candidate must have previous experience and be ready to work flexible hours. Apply at info@tg.com.mt SNF OPERATORS- we are seeking to recruit staff for the position of Water sports Jetty helper. Please send an email on info@sunfunmalta.com