Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1499488
OPINION Jonathan Este is Associate Editor, International Affairs Editor 12 maltatoday | WEDNESDAY • 17 MAY 2023 ONE tank. According to press reports and news broadcasts from Moscow, a solitary T-34 dating back to the second world war was the only tank that trun- dled past the Russian president as he marked a scaled-down Vic- tory Day on May 9 this year. As we have previously not- ed here, Victory Day parades are a big deal for Vladimir Pu- tin. During his time in power he has transformed them from a solemn (if obviously martial) commemoration of the part the Red Army played in the defeat of Nazism in the second world war to a macho demonstration of imperial might. It's now one of Russia's most important nation- al celebrations. A clearly piqued Putin told the (rather smaller than usual) crowds in Red Square that "a re- al war has again been unleashed" on Russia, a reprise of his oft-ar- ticulated theme that the whole thing is actually a conflict forced upon the motherland by evil forces in the west. Presumably Russia needs all its military hardware at the front as it prepares for a spring offensive that is expected to begin any day now. Indeed, the respected US- based thinktank the Institute for the Study of War has flagged what it is calling "successful limited counterattacks" around Bakhmut. Russian troops have been bogged down there for months in a murderous and at- tritional slugfest at a huge cost in terms of both lives and ammuni- tion. But anyone thinking that the much-heralded offensive will be the prelude to a swift Ukrainian victory on the battlefield is mis- taken, writes Frank Ledwidge, a former military intelligence of- ficer now researching and teach- ing military strategy at the Uni- versity of Portsmouth. Ledwidge has recently returned from Kyiv where he attended a confer- ence organised by the thinktank Globsec. "One abiding impression re- mains," he writes, "the profound determination of Ukrainian peo- ple to fight what almost every- one now accepts is going to be a long war. At no level is there any appetite for settlement or cease- fire." But there are also no illu- sions that the spring offensive will be decisive and Ukraine is going to need western help – and lots of it – for some years yet. Russian masculinity One thing is certain though. The heavy toll this is taking on Russia's troops – whether regu- lar army or the various private militias, of which the now-noto- rious Wagner Group is but one – means that there will have to be another major round of con- scription. The Russian Duma recently rubberstamped legislation that will make it significantly harder for young Russian men to avoid the call-up. Last September when Putin announced Russia's first mobilisation since the sec- ond world war, there was a gen- eral rush for the exits. Hundreds of thousands of draft-eligible young men headed for the safety of neighbouring countries rather than join up. Russians have been treated to a blitz of advertising appeal- ing to the Russian male's sense of their "warrior masculinity". Marina Yusupova of Edinburgh Napier University is an expert in expressions of masculinity – particularly in Russia – and has researched Russian men's views on the army and military service. She says while there is a huge amount of respect for the So- viet-era military, today's army holds little appeal for most men – who tend to see it as "corrupt", "deeply damaged" and "discred- ited". Appeals along the lines of "You're a real man, be one" – as one advert implores – are un- likely to be as effective as Putin might hope. Muscovites got a nasty shock one night last week when two drones exploded close to the Kremlin itself. This sparked in- tense speculation, not least from Putin himself who immediately announced that this was a das- tardly attempt at assassination. "A planned terrorist act and an attempt on the president's life, carried out on the eve of Victo- ry Day", his office declared. This blithely ignores the fact that it's not exactly a state secret that Putin rarely if ever sleeps over at the Kremlin, so this would be a particularly futile attempt to bump him off. Kyiv has flatly denied having any part in the attack. But, as Da- vid Dunn and Stefan Wolff of the University of Birmingham note, Putin has form when it comes to false flag operations. They argue there could be myriad reasons for Russia to have staged what they see as a piece of badly man- aged theatre. Read more: Ukraine war: drone 'attack' on Kremlin – log- ic suggests a false flag to distract Russians ahead of Victory Day on May 9 China syndrome Putin's war in Ukraine has given Xi Jinping the opportu- nity to walk the world stage as ostensible peacemaker. Despite declaring "friendship without limits" with Putin when the pair met a couple of days before the invasion last February, China has since sat on the fence diplo- matically, It has abstained from voting on United Nations res- olutions condemning the war but also, thus far, refrained from supplying Russia with military equipment. As Natasha Kuhrt from Kings College London and Marcin Kaczmarski from the University of Glasgow note, Xi and his ad- visers will be thinking through the various possible outcomes of the war. Here they give us three possible scenarios. Xi also called the Ukrainian president last week for the first time since the conflict began. As Stefan Wolff notes, there's a lot at stake for China – what- ever the outcomes. One the one hand it needs Russia for balance in its great power competition with the west. On the other, var- ious senior EU representatives have made it clear that Beijing's stance on the war will signifi- cantly influence the future of Eu- rope's relationship with China. But if Xi pulls off a diplomat- ic solution, writes Wolff, it will further cement China's status as an important power broker in a bipolar order. Nowhere to hide for Putin? The International Criminal Court's recent decision to issue an arrest warrant for Putin for war crimes associated with the alleged kidnapping of Ukrainian children was greeted with a de- gree of weary cynicism all round. As US president Joe Biden not- ed at the time, the International Criminal Court "is not recog- nised by us either". But, as Aaron Fichtelberg, an expert in criminal justice at the University of Delaware notes, it would be rash to assume that Putin is safe from the court's grasp. Fichtelberg runs through a number of former strongman leaders who have faced justice, not just at the hands of the ICC but a variety of other ad hoc le- gal jurisdictions set up to try war crimes. And, he adds, life as a fu- gitive – even as a former head of state – can be pretty miserable, as the late former Chilean dicta- tor Augusto Pinochet found out in the 1990s. Not a great deal to celebrate for Putin this Victory Day Jonathan Este A World War II ages Soviet army T-34 tank rolls during the Victory Day military parade at Dvortsovaya (Palace) Square to celebrate 78 years after the victory in World War II in St. Petersburg, Russia, Tuesday, May 9, 2023. (AP Photo/Dmitri Lovetsky)