Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1510993
maltatoday | SUNDAY • 5 NOVEMBER 2023 11 LAW CLASSIFIEDS THE Court of Appeal annulled an appeal on the ground that the appeal was dealing with the merits of the case and not on a point of law. This was held in Robert Dimech vs Air Malta plc on 1 November 2023 by the Court of Appeal, presided by Mr Justice Lawrence Mintoff. The Industrial Tribunal had ruled on 7 February 2023 that Air Malta was guilty for 60% and Dimech was responsible for 40% for his termination of employ- ment following a disciplinary board finding. Dimech filed pro- ceedings before the Tribunal. He asked for the Tribunal to declare his termination from Air Malta was unjustified and the discipli- nary proceedings were discrim- inatory. Air Malta defended itself by saying that it had valid reasons for dismissing Dimech. The dis- ciplinary proceedings were tak- en according to the Collective Agreement and there was no pressure from the Chairman at the time. The Tribunal argued that it had a hard task since both sides presented convincing argu- ments. The issue was that Di- mech did some physical training at his place of work and then arranged his clothes in front of his colleagues. Then he placed tape on the door of his office to see whether anyone entered the office. The Tribunal said that he had an obsession on a colleague, who according to him was free to leave work at any time. The obsession went a step further where Dimech asked about her personal life, and he should have known that he overstepped the mark. The Tribunal compared the explanations of harassment and quoted from an author Norman Selwun who categorised three different types of harassment. Then there was the legislative explanation in Article 29 of the Employment and Industrial Re- lations Act, where an employer or employee cannot harass an- other employee: "29. (1) It shall not be lawful for an employer or an employee to harass another employee or to harass the employer by subject- ing such person to any unwel- come act, request or conduct, including spoken words, ges- tures or the production, display or circulation of written words, pictures or other material, which in respect of that person is based on sexual discrimination and which could reasonably be re- garded as offensive, humiliating or intimidating to such person." The Tribunal agreed with the Appeals Board of Air Malta that there was harassment, although it was not sexual harassment. The Tribunal labelled this as an offensive mode of conduct. This resulted in his dismissal. The Tri- bunal also held that the airline was responsible for contributary negligence, it was of the opinion that the company was not total- ly in good faith. The evidence showed that Dimech was a good employee in that he was diligent and professional on the job and worked in the company's inter- est. The Tribunal felt that all in all, the company was too harsh with Dimech when it terminated his job, especially when the dis- ciplinary board did not find him guilty of the most serious charge, that of sexual harassment. The Tribunal felt that the airline wanted an excuse to terminate Dimech's employment. On the issue of compensation, the Tribunal held it was guided on Court of Appeal judgements such as Carmel Borg vs Malta Transport Services (Operations) Limited decided on 9 March 2019 and Marco Pisani vs The AV Warehouse Limited, decid- ed on 11 February 2019. Dimech held that his loss was over €112, 000, but the Tribunal considered that his age and the fact that it was partially his fault that he was dismissed. Air Malta appealed the deci- sion on the basis that the deci- sion was legally erroneous and that it went against the principle that the other party should be heard (audi alteram partem). Dimech replied stating that the appeal is null because it did not follow Article 82(3) of the Employment and Industrial Re- lations Act. The law dictates that appeals should be based on points of law. The appeal dealt with the merits of the case such as the compensation and the contributory factor of the com- pany. The Court of Appeal dealt im- mediately on whether the appeal referred to a point of law. The Court pointed out that the ap- peal did not deal with any point of law and only dealt with how the Tribunal analysed the evi- dence. The Appellant tried to mask the ground of appeal of au- di alteram partem by saying that the Tribunal did not consider all the evidence that the company brought before it. The Appellant company quoted from authors and previous judgments, howev- er, the Court of Appeal held that the examples given are not ap- plicable to this case. Therefore, the Court held it has no option but to agree that the appeal was not admissible because it did not deal with points of law. Dimech had filed an incidental appeal and the Court of Appeal applied the principle that once the appeal itself was attacked, then one cannot make use of the appeal as though it is valid (elec- ta una via non datur recursus ad altera). Therefore, the court moved to turn down both appeals. Appeals from Industrial Tribunal should be only on points of law HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION MARSALFORN, Gozo - holiday apart- ments for short or long lets with mag- nificent sea-views. Call 21556021, 27556021, 79426883 PROPERTY TO LET SHOP TO LEASE - Class 4 B 60 sqm corner shop to lease in San Gwann. Key money €49,888 and €40 a day rental. Call on 79703404. XLENDI - catering premises in prime site to let. Can be used for other com- mercial purposes. Phone 79493021, 79426883, 77481592 or 77484029 SITUATIONS VACANT PROPE RT Y MAINTENANCE - Xuereb Installations Ltd seek to recruit on a full-time basis a "Property Maintenance". The ideal candidate should be responsible, organized, and self-motivated. Experience is required. The main tasks will be conducting rou- tine maintenance tasks, ensure a safe and efficient work environment. The rate is 7.50 /hr. Interested candidates must send CV with photo by the 15th November 2023 by email to: s.cachia@ xuerebinstall.com HOUSEKEEPER required for a full- time, Live-In position within a family home with outside areas. Must be reli- able and communicate well in English and Portuguese. Please WhatsApp your CV to 99496677, and if foreign, kindly advise your Visa status. SECURIT Y OFFICER - Torri Gardens LTD in Lija requires the ser vices of a Security Night Officer on full- time basis. Must have a knowledge of English. The ideal candidate must have previous experience and be ready to work flexible hours. Apply info@ tg.com.mt SIGNAL 8 -Signal 8 Security Malta Ltd. requires filling the following positions as Customer Care Clerks, Security Guards, security for places of entertainment and cleaners. Applicants should be customer care orientated, smart and flexible for shift work. Email your CV to: hr@signal8securitymalta. com.mt VACANCIES - D.J.S Turnkey Solutions of Hamrun have the following posi- tions available; A/C mechanic and technicians, lift installer and techni- cians, electrician and electrical install- er. Required qualification -1 diploma in relevant fields and O, level and must be fluent in English. A minimum of three years' experience and preferably overseas experience. Kindly send your CV to dcdebono7969@gmail.com or by post to - D.J.S Turnkey Solutions Ltd. 4, Emerald, Triq Pietru Xuereb, Hamrun. WA I T E R / WA I T R E S S - required for busy hotel restaurant in Naxxar. Must be fluent in English, be able to work flexible hours including week- ends and public holidays. Min 3 years' experience in similar position. Call +365 2798 8357 for more info - The Village Hotel LTD. CLASSIFIEDS INFO @MEDIATODAY.COM.MT LAW REPORT MALCOLM MIFSUD Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates