Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1525930
11 EDITORIAL maltatoday | WEDNESDAY • 28 AUGUST 2024 WHEN Nicolette Ghirxi was murdered we were told by the Police Commissioner that after report- ing the messages and emails she had received from her ex-partner, Nicolette refused to undergo a risk assessment. The Foundation for Social Welfare Services, responsible for Appogg, had also suggested that Nicolette turned down the offer to undergo a risk assessment at the hands of social workers. It was also suggested that the nature of the messages she had received from her eventual killer were insults rather than threats, implying that even if she accepted the assessment it may have given a low to zero risk outcome. Nonetheless, new information has emerged since then suggesting that Nicolette may have been talked out of a risk assessment by the pro- fessionals involved in her case. A voice message Nicolette sent to someone close to her on the day she filed the police report appears to sup- port this thesis. The FSWS has stood by the version given by its social workers, insisting no such incident oc- curred. The police has remained silent on the basis that an internal investigation is under- way to determine how the police behaved and whether the systems worked well. In these circumstances it is pertinent that the facts are established and an analysis is undertak- en of the reporting systems in domestic violence cases. Given the new information that has emerged, the fact that just four days before her murder Nicolette had reported to the police that her ex-partner could be in Malta and they did noth- ing about it, takes on greater relevance. An internal investigation by the Police Board is not enough. This will only look into the actions of the police officers. Nicolette's lawyer is right when he says that in a situation where different agencies are involved - the police and Appogg - a wider probe is required that will also delve into the dynamic between the different agencies. This leader supports calls made by various quarters, including the Opposition, for a public inquiry with full powers to look into the sys- tems, procedures and behaviour of professionals involved in handling domestic violence cases. Nicolette's case may have a different dynamic than that of Bernice Cassar, which had triggered an independent inquiry (not a public inquiry) that led to several suggestions. Nonetheless, the latest femicide shows that there are still glaring gaps in the manner by which domestic violence cases are handled and followed up. A public inquiry into Nicolette's murder will hopefully establish whether there were any fail- ings by the professionals involved in her case or whether the failings are the result of inadequate procedures that may not be sensitive enough to capture what would initially appear as border- line cases. But a public inquiry will also serve to gauge any progress, or lack of it, achieved since the Bernice murder and make recommendations for further change. The government should avoid another show of force with the victim's relatives as it did on the Jean Paul Sofia inquiry and agree to holding a public inquiry into Nicolette's murder. The Prime Minister, Home Affairs Minister Byron Camilleri and Parliamentary Secretary Rebecca Buttigieg should step up and take the initiative without further delay. We just hope that the government has learnt its lesson from the Sofia debacle. It is in the national interest to fully understand how the State is dealing with domestic violence cases and whether victims are being afforded adequate protection. Nicolette's murder is just another brutal re- minder that a lot more still needs to be done, not least to bring about a cultural change in attitude. We just hope the government avoids the sense- less and useless tug of war with the victim's rel- atives and women's rights campaigners. This is the time for everyone to pull on the same side of the rope in the best interests of victims. A public inquiry at this stage - not in a year's time - is the right thing to do. A public inquiry into Nicolette's murder is needed maltatoday MaltaToday, MediaToday Co. Ltd, Vjal ir-Rihan, San Gwann SGN 9016 MANAGING EDITOR: SAVIOUR BALZAN EXECUTIVE EDITOR: KURT SANSONE EDITOR: PAUL COCKS Tel: (356) 21 382741-3, 21 382745-6 Website: www.maltatoday.com.mt E-mail: dailynews@mediatoday.com.mt ducing misinformation and the impact of scams. Regulation and policy also play a vital role. Governments and regulatory bodies must es- tablish clear guidelines for us- ing GenAI, ensuring that ethi- cal standards are upheld. This might include requiring ex- plicit labelling of AI-generated content, implementing stricter privacy protections, and en- forcing penalties for the misuse of these technologies. Collaboration across sectors is necessary to combat dig- ital sludge effectively. Tech companies, policymakers, re- searchers, and civil society or- ganisations must work togeth- er to develop comprehensive strategies. This could involve creating shared databases of malicious activities, develop- ing better tools for detecting AI-generated content, and pro- moting best practices for ethi- cal AI use. Moreover, there is a need for continuous monitoring and adaptation. As GenAI technol- ogies evolve, so will the tactics used by malicious actors. On- going research and surveillance are needed to avoid emerging threats and develop new coun- termeasures. This dynamic approach will ensure that pro- tections remain effective in the face of rapidly advancing tech- nologies. While GenAI offers tremen- dous potential for innovation and progress, its misuse is creating a significant problem of digital sludge. The manip- ulation of human likeness, the spread of misinformation, the facilitation of scams, and the production of low-quality con- tent all contribute to a polluted digital environment. Address- ing these challenges requires a comprehensive approach that includes technical solutions, public education, regulatory frameworks, and collaborative efforts. By taking proactive measures, we can harness the benefits of GenAI while miti- gating its risks, ensuring a safer and more trustworthy digital landscape for everyone.