Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1547597
12 maltatoday | WEDNESDAY • 18 NOVEMBER 2026 NEWS WITH SAVIOUR BALZAN THURSDAY AT 10.15PM ON TVM MAYA GALEA mgalea@mediatoday.com.mt Lilu King files constitutional proceedings to regain refugee status, fearing torture in Libya LILU King, also known as Mo- hamed Ali Ahmed Elmushraty, has filed constitutional proceed- ings in a bid to regain his refu- gee status in Malta. He is argu- ing that deportation to Tunisia could ultimately see him sent back to Libya, where he fears persecution and torture. The constitutional application, filed against the State Advocate, the Attorney General and the In- ternational Protection Agency (IPA), challenges the agency's re- fusal to restore Elmushraty's refu- gee status. The lawyers argue that the de- cision violates his fundamental rights under the European Con- vention on Human Rights, includ- ing protection against torture and inhuman or degrading treatment and the right to a fair trial. Elmushraty was originally grant- ed refugee status on 5 December 2015, after the Office of the Ref- ugee Commissioner concluded that he satisfied the requirements for protection. However, on 23 May 2023, the International Pro- tection Agency decided that his refugee status had expired. He subsequently applied on 12 June 2023 to have his refugee sta- tus restored but his request was rejected by the agency on 11 Sep- tember 2026. Defence warns Tunisia deporta- tion could lead to forced return to Libya At the heart of the constitution- al challenge is the argument that the authorities failed to properly assess the risk of Elmushraty ul- timately being sent back to Libya. The IPA concluded that he could be deported to Tunisia rather than Libya, effectively treating his previously expressed fears of re- turning to Libya as irrelevant. The tribunal based its reason- ing on the fact that Elmushraty's mother is Tunisian and that he was born in Tunisia, concluding that he had automatically ac- quired Tunisian nationality under the relevant law. The defence disputes this, argu- ing that Elmushraty is not formal- ly recognised as a Tunisian citizen and has no guarantee of being granted citizenship if he applies for it. His lawyers also claim that he is barred from entering Tunisia, warning that the Tunisian author- ities could send him onwards to Libya, exposing him to the very dangers from which he was orig- inally granted refugee protection. They further argue that the IPA failed to seek assurances from Tu- nisian authorities that Elmushraty would not be deported to Libya. Elmushraty's fears of returning to Libya stem from his and his family's alleged connections to former Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi. Elmushraty claims he was previously arrested in Lib- ya, detained without ever being brought before a court and sub- jected to torture without being afforded a fair hearing. Elmushraty maintains that the circumstances which originally led to him being granted refugee status have not changed. Pending criminal charges cannot justify deportation Elmushraty's defence also argues that the refusal to restore his ref- ugee status appears to have been influenced by several pending criminal proceedings against him. His lawyers maintain that the existence of criminal charges cannot, in itself, justify deporting someone to a country where they face a genuine risk of torture or inhuman treatment. Citing sev- eral judgments of the European Court of Human Rights, his law- yers argue that the prohibition against torture and inhuman or degrading treatment under Ar- ticle 3 of the European Conven- tion is absolute, meaning that it cannot be overridden even by national security concerns or an individual's criminal history. Among the pending cases are charges relating to organised crime, money laundering and alleged involvement in a violent sexual assault at a San Ġwann butcher shop. He also faces pro- ceedings over an alleged assault in Sliema. Separately, Libyan authorities formally requested Elmushraty's extradition from Malta in September in connec- tion with serious criminal alle- gations, including murder and drug trafficking. Elmushraty is now requesting the court, to declare that the refusal to restore his refugee status breaches his fundamen- tal rights. He is also seeking an effective remedy, including the annulment of the International Protection Agency's decision. The constitutional applica- tion was filed by lawyers Franco Debono, Marion Camilleri, José Herrera and Martina Herrera.
