Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1547597
THE government justified its decision to introduce new fees and remove certain benefits for third country nationals (TCNs) on the basis that no country provides every service free of charge to people who have just arrived. Abela nevertheless started off his defence by erroneously be- lieving and misleadingly assert- ing that most TCNs aren't paid peanuts, whereas public figures show that in 2024, 34.4% of all non-EU citizens earned €12,000 or less, while 75% of all TCNs earned no more than €20,000. The measures, among which are increases in the initial work permit application fee and the annual renewal fee, together with the removal of free child- care and public transport in addition to car usage charges, raised concerns over the finan- cial burden on third country na- tionals, as well as the impact on their ability to live and work in Malta. Their dignity and respect have been jeopardised. Equality Minister Rosianne Cutajar was equally concerned. The whole issue raises many legal considerations in light of the applicable EU legislation on the subject. Third country nationals who work in the EU for a short time are among the workers often subject to pivotal exclusions. A fragmented legal framework governs TCNs' entitlement to equal treatment with nationals of the host Member State re- garding access to social benefits under EU law. Access to social advantages for TCNs is shaped by detailed EU secondary legis- lation, which defines rights and obligations based on an individ- ual's specific legal status. While EU secondary legisla- tion establishes differentiated rules depending on migration status, its transposition and implementation at the national level remain inconsistent. Some member states provide TCNs with broader access to welfare systems, while others impose more restrictive eligibility crite- ria, as Malta has now done. There is abundant case law from the European Court of Jus- tice (ECJ) concerning the equal treatment provisions in three key migration directives: Di- rective 2003/109 on long-term residents, Directive 2011/95 on beneficiaries of internation- al protection, and Directive 2024/1233 on the Single Permit. Moreover, the Charter of Fun- damental Rights might help address the fragmentation sur- rounding TCNs' access to so- cial benefits. Special attention is given to the role of Article 20 in guiding the interpretation and evaluation of exclusionary or discriminatory measures and to the potential of Article 34 in guaranteeing a dignified stand- ard of living by establishing core minimum standards. Such standards would limit Mem- ber States' discretion, including Malta's, in regulating access to social benefits and reduce the legal uncertainty associated with case-by-case assessments by national courts. While EU primary law reflects the institutional and political objectives of EU law, which seek to strike a balance between fos- tering inclusivity and preserv- ing member state sovereignty in areas such as immigration and the treatment of TCNs, this approach has resulted in a frag- mented legal framework for pro- tecting the rights of third-coun- try nationals, leaving their entitlements heavily reliant on the provisions of secondary leg- islation rather than enjoying the same guarantees provided to EU citizens under primary law. The principle of equal treat- ment plays a significant role in the development of the com- mon immigration policy within the European Union. Yet certain EU directives explicitly exclude specific categories of foreigners, such as short-term visa holders or temporary residents, from the scope of equal treatment protections. As a result, the application of equal treatment among TCNs is uneven, creat- ing disparities based on residen- cy status or purpose of stay. Furthermore, TCNs face sig- nificant barriers due to meas- ures imposed by several mem- ber states, which have been reviewed in cases before the court. These measures include, for instance, restrictions on housing benefits justified by budgetary concerns, require- ments for long-term residents to demonstrate basic language proficiency as a condition for accessing housing assistance, limitations on social assistance for beneficiaries of international protection, and strict residency requirements to qualify for so- cial benefits. Such policies create substan- tial challenges for TCNs and raise serious questions about their compliance with EU law and the principle of equal treat- ment. Nevertheless, member states frequently defend these restrictive measures by invoking the notion of national solidar- ity, arguing that social benefits should be reserved for individ- uals who demonstrate integra- tion into the host society either through contributions to social systems or proof of integration. We need to consider that most welfare benefits can be divided into two categories—social as- sistance and social security. The court clarified the difference between these categories in the Frilli case of 1972. Accord- ing to the ECJ, social assistance seeks to relieve a state of need or poverty: it is the need that causes and justifies the right to assistance. Furthermore, the court specified in the Dano and Alimanovic cases that social as- sistance refers to 'all assistance schemes established by the pub- lic authorities, whether at na- tional, regional or local level, to which recourse may be had by an individual who does not have resources sufficient to meet his or her basic needs and those of his or her family'. By contrast, social security is not focused on alleviating poverty but rather on indemnifying individuals against certain social risks by providing a supplementary or substitute income. Its purpose is to replace or supplement income rather than to provide a specific level of financial support. The government's latest re- strictive measures overlook the contributions of TCNs to the Maltese economy, particularly through their work and tax pay- ments. This failure highlights a disregard for the importance of equal treatment for non-EU citi- zens in the affected areas, which could lead to unfair competition and exploitation between these individuals and Maltese nation- als. 10 maltatoday | WEDNESDAY • 18 NOVEMBER 2026 OPINION The predicament of TCNs Mark Said Veteran lawyer The government's latest restrictive measures overlook the contributions of TCNs to the Maltese economy, particularly through their work and tax payments

