MediaToday Newspapers Latest Editions

MALTATODAY 22 NOVEMBER 2026

Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1547680

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 31 of 39

12 maltatoday | SUNDAY • 22 NOVEMBER 2026 LAW Two missed deadlines, one failed deportation GIANLUCA CAPPITTA Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates IN a judgment delivered on 4 November 2026, the court upheld an earlier decision by the Immigration Appeals Board anul- ling a man's return decision and removal order. The case highlights the importance of following legal deadlines, particularly when decisions can result in someone losing their right to remain in the coun- try. The case began in August 2026, when immigration officials found the man at the offices of a business where he was not authorised to work. He already held a valid residence and employment per- mit linked to his full-time job with an- other company. The authorities alleged that he was al- so carrying out work for a second busi- ness, contrary to the conditions of his permit. The man denied this, explain- ing that he used the second business's services and had visited its offices to obtain assistance with his account and funds. On 13 August 2026, the immigration authorities issued a return decision and removal order, requiring him to leave Malta, and placed the man in deten- tion. He also faced an entry ban of up to three years covering Malta and the Schengen area. An appeal and two missed deadlines The man challenged the decision be- fore the Immigration Appeals Board. Given that the removal documents con- tained only general reasons for the al- leged breach, the board instructed the immigration authorities to submit their evidence and written arguments first, so that the man could understand and respond to the accusations. The authorities were told to file their documents by 28 August. They missed that deadline. On 31 August, the board issued a further urgent instruction re- questing the documents that same day. That deadline was also missed. The documents were eventually sub- mitted on 4 September, without an ex- planation for the delay or a request to extend the deadline. Apart from factually challenging the allegations of unauthorised work lev- elled against him, the man challenged the admissibility of the immigration authorities' submissions and support- ing documents, arguing that they had been filed after the prescribed deadline. He therefore requested that the late submis- sions and documents be expunged from the proceedings and disregarded. On 17 September, the board ruled that the late submissions and supporting doc- uments could not be considered. Without that material, the board found insufficient admissible evidence to establish that the man had been carrying out unauthorised work. It therefore annulled the return de- cision and removal order, together with any entry ban. Why the Court rejected the authorities' appeal The immigration authorities appealed, arguing that the board had incorrectly changed the usual order of written submis- sions. Under the applicable regulations, a person challenging an immigration deci- sion would normally produce evidence and submissions first, followed by the authori- ties. The court rejected that argument. It explained that the board has the power to manage proceedings and, where appropri- ate, require the authority making an alle- gation to present its evidence first. In this case, the board's approach was reasonable because the authorities were in posses- sion of the information used to justify the removal measures. The court also noted that the immigration authorities had not objected when the board originally gave its instructions. Instead, they failed to comply with two deadlines and challenged the pro- cedure only after the decision went against them. The judgment emphasised that pro- cedural deadlines exist for a reason. Immi- gration cases should be resolved quickly, especially when serious consequences for personal liberty are involved. Since the appeal is technically limited to points of procedure only, the court did not delve into whether the man was actually carrying unauthorised work or not. Rather, it confirmed that the board was entitled to exclude the late evidence and the removal measures could not stand on the admissible material before it. Continued detention and eventual release Despite winning his appeal before the board, the man remained in detention while the authorities pursued their chal- lenge in the Court of Magistrates. In the meantime, the man challenged his continued detention through separate ha- beas corpus proceedings, arguing that he should no longer be deprived of his liberty following the board's decision. However, the court rejected his applica- tion, finding that his initial detention had been lawful and that the board's decision was not yet final because the immigration authorities had appealed. The court also explained that its powers in habeas corpus proceedings were limited and that the ap- propriate remedy was to seek a review of his detention before the Court of Appeal under the Immigration Act. The situation changed on 4 November 2026, when the Court of Appeal dis- missed the immigration authorities' appeal. With the return decision and removal order definitively annulled, the court found no basis for his con- tinued detention and consequently or- dered the man's immediate release. The man was represented by lawyer Gianluca Cappitta.

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of MediaToday Newspapers Latest Editions - MALTATODAY 22 NOVEMBER 2026