Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1330252
maltatoday | SUNDAY • 17 JANUARY 2021 15 A court may not be competent to hear a counter-claim because that claim is lower than the threshold in which the court may hear cases. This was decid- ed by the Magistrates' Court, presided by Magistrate Victor Axiaq in RX Construction Lim- ited -v- Jesmond Friggieri. The plaintiff company is suing the defendant, Jesmond Frig- gieri for €10,182.50 for con- struction works carried out in a property in Mosta and for loss of earnings when the compa- ny was stopped without a valid reason at law. Friggieri argued that the works were not carried out accord- ing to professional standards and filed a counter-claim of €5,000 for damages, as he had to engage another construction company to finish the job. RX Construction Limited filed a statement of defence for the counter-claim and pleaded that the Magistrates' Court was not competent to hear the coun- ter-claim and the claim should have been presented before the Small Claims Tribunal. This plea falls under Article 741(b) of the Code of Organisation and Civil Procedure. The Plaintiff Company held that the counter claim of €5,000 is less than the Magistrates' Court's competence and should be dealt with by the Small Claims Tribunal. The defend- ant held that it does not make sense that the action should be divided into two different courts. The Plaintiff Company quot- ed from Jason Azzopardi -v- Marija Bartolo decided by the First Hall of the Civil Court on 12 March 2019. This case con- cerned the removal of a gar- nishee order after Marija Bar- tolo filed for a counter-claim of €15,000, which claim falls un- der the Magistrates' Court and not the First Hall of the Civil Courts. The Court upheld the appli- cation to revoke the garnishee order and argued that ignore its competence on the basis that the claim is in fact a coun- ter-claim of a larger sum. The main claim does not force a court to hear a counter-claim if that Court is not competent. In another judgement Ghei- ti and Sons Limited -v- Perit Arkitett Colin Zammit decid- ed by the First hall of the Civil Court on 19 May 2011. In this judgement the court held that the claim and counter-claim are in fact two actions, which can have an independent ex- istence. Therefore, if the Court is not competent to hear, then this point cannot be ignored because it would duplicate the actions. Magistrate Axiak pointed out that the Plaintiff Company is claiming payment for works it carried out and for loss of earn- ings. The defendant put up a counter-claim. This falls under Article 396 of the Code of Or- ganisation and Civil Procedure (COCP), which reads: "In any action, it shall be law- ful for the defendant to set up a counter-claim against the plaintiff, provided the claim of the defendant be connected with the claim of the plaintiff as stated hereunder (a) if the claim of the defend- ant arises from the same factor from the same contract or title giving rise to the claim of the plaintiff; or (b) if the object of the claim of the defendant is to set-off the debt claimed by the plaintiff, or to bar in any other manner the action of the plaintiff, or to pre- clude its effects" Article 397 of the COCP stat- ed that the claim and coun- ter-claim are to be held in one action and to be decided to- gether. Therefore, in this case the ba- sis of the claim and the coun- ter-claim were derived from the same contract. The Court quot- ed from the Italian Code of Civ- il Procedure, where a judge will hear both the main claim and counter-claim, unless there is an issue on the competence of the court. If the counter-claim exceeds the competence of the Italian Court, then the action may be referred to the superior court or else separate the claim and counter claim. There is no such provision in Maltese legis- lation. Article 744 of the COCP states that a counter-claim extends the jurisdiction of the Court but not the competence. It makes clear that the counter-claim may be referred to another Court. The Court was of the opinion that this may take place when the counter-claim has a different value of the Court it is before. The Court disagreed with the Defendant who argued that the counter-claim was worded "€5,000 or any other sum". Al- though any other sum could be more or less than €5,000, this still falls under the competency of the Small Claims Tribunal. Magistrate Axiak then dis- cussed what to do with the case if it finds that it does not have the necessary competency to continue to hear the coun- ter-claim. The 2016 and 2018 amend- ments to the COCP allow the Court to order that the acts of the case be transferred to an- other court or tribunal, but if that court or tribunal do not agree that it is competent, then the acts are sent to the Court of Appeal to decide which court should hear the case. The Court, in the case, said since the claim and counter-claims are two different actions, it will transfer the acts by means of a separate decree. The Magistrates' Court then moved to uphold the plea of lack of competence. LAW CLASSIFIEDS CLASSIFIEDS INFO @MEDIATODAY.COM.MT Court may not be competent to hear a counter-claim due to the sum claimed HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION MARSALFORN, Gozo - holiday apart- ments for short or long lets with mag- nificent sea-views. Call 21556021, 27556021, 79426883 PROPERTY TO LET XLENDI - catering premises in prime site to let. Can be used for other com- mercial purposes. Phone 79493021, 79426883, 77481592 or 77484029 PROPERTY FOR SALE QAWRA – Calling all developers this is an ideal development opportunity. Presently a 3 bedroomed penthouse with own airspace on the outskirts of Qawra close to Kennedy Grove, not far from the new primary school and main bus routes. Two double bedrooms and 1 single bedroom, two bathrooms, lift, double glazing doors and windows. With the option to build up a fur- ther 3 floors. Offers in the region of €310k. Once developed these apart- ments would be a strategic rental invest- ment or resale opportunity. Kindly mes- sage owner on 99201846. NO AGENTS. SAN GWANN- Open plan 190sqm, ready to move into designer finished second floor apartment in a central quiet street forming part of a block of 5 apartments. Two double A/C bed- rooms and 1 single A/C bedroom, two bathrooms, lift, double glazing doors and windows. Direct from owner €350k inquire on 79402244. TARXIEN - Larger than usual first floor duplex maisonette. Three bedrooms; double glazed windows; inverter air conditioners including solar water heat- er. Being sold furnished. Own airspace with possibility of further development. Contact owner on 99912005/99450639. SERVICES NEWSPAPER adverts - Book & pay on-line on www.perfecta.com.mt - no extra charges. Call on 21322452 SITUATIONS VACANT OASIS TRAVEL AND TOURISM - we are seeking to recruit staff for Delivery drivers and AC Technicians. Kindly send your CV to philip@citysightsee- ing.com.mt LABOURERS - OZOMALTA is seeking to recruit individuals to work as labour- ers. The chosen candidates must be able to speak and write fluently in English. Kindly apply by sending a detailed CV to careers@ozogroup.com SIGNAL 8 - Signal 8 Security Malta Ltd. requires filling positions as Customer Care Clerks, Security Guards, security for places of entertainment and clean- ers. Applicants should be customer care orientated, smart and flexible for shift work. Email your CV to hr@signal8se- curitymalta.com.mt SPA THERAPIST - Required for a bou- tique hotel. Full time hours including weekends and public holidays. Must be flexible with hours. At least 5 years' experience in a similar post. Must be specialised in colonic irrigation. For more info please call Village Concept on 99885352. R B U I L D I N G E N E R G Y TECHNOLOGIES LTD – located in San Gwann, has job positions for General labourers & General Construction Cleaners in roads construction. Applicants must have experience, flu- ently speak English and other languag- es. Hourly rate Eur4.50. Interested applicants may send e-mail to: secre- tary@a-plusplus.eu. CLEANER – TP Carparks require an experienced cleaner. The applicant must have 3 years experience and possess a good level of spoken and written English. You must be flexible, hard- working & self-motivated, previous experience will be considered an asset. Be highly professional with a pro-active approach. Be a team-player willing to work in a rapidly changing and dynamic environment. Interested individuals can apply by email: christian.miggiani@dte- malta.com or call on: (356) 99995034. PROPERTY SALES CONSULTANT - An Estate Agency forming part of a large group of companies is currently looking for an Experienced Full Time or Part-Time Property Sales Consultant to join their team on Self-Employed Basis. The chosen candidates should possess 2+ years of experience in prop- erty market with proven sales record. To apply send a detailed CV to careers@ ozogroup.com quoting job reference 96-002-JAN.2021. WANTED COLLECTIBLE items such panini albums and loose stickers, old postcards and posted envelopes, medals, militar- ia, coins and paper money, books, toys, stamps, badges, paintings, gold & silver items etc. Call on 21310238, 99246632 LAW REPORT MALCOLM MIFSUD Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates