Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1501168
6 maltatoday | SUNDAY • 27 MARCH 2022 OPINION 2 maltatoday EXECUTIVE EDITOR KURT SANSONE ksansone@mediatoday.com.mt Letters to the Editor, MaltaToday, Vjal ir-Rihan, San Gwann SGN 9016 E-mail: dailynews@mediatoday.com.mt Letters must be concise, no pen names accepted, include full name and address maltatoday | SUNDAY • 11 JUNE 2023 Abortion: Uncomfortably numb Editorial ROBERT Abela is arguably the first Maltese Prime Minister to openly speak about the realities of abor- tion from the woman's perspective, and to push for a change in legislation. Meek though government's attempt may be, to decriminalise abortion in two very limited circum- stances – if a woman's life is in danger, or her health is in grave jeopardy – it has to be recognised for what it is; a bold attempt to change Malta's draconian an- ti-abortion law. For this, Abela and his government must be com- mended. Abortion is and has always been a political minefield; one which neither Dom Mintoff nor Joseph Muscat dared to touch, despite their domineering sta- tus within the Labour Party. Abela and his Deputy Prime Minister Chris Fearne have had to push against the conservative forces in this country – which seem to have found common purpose, in opposing the legal changes – and the more traditionalist elements within their own party. There have also been times, recently, when abortion was simply a tar word to smear political opponents with; a situation that forced pro-choice politicians into abject silence. Thankfully, times have changed. Young female pol- iticians, primarily from the Labour fold, are increas- ingly voicing their pro-choice views without yester- year's fear of being ostracised – unless they militate within the Nationalist Party. More and more people from different walks of life are coming forward to assert their pro-choice views – having a well-attended public pro-choice demon- stration that also includes doctors would have been unthinkable until five years ago. However, this leader understands that the vast majority in the country still views abortion as a crimi- nal act that should be discouraged and even punished. This complex tapestry is not easy to navigate for any politician, which is why Abela's leadership in this debate is important. The Labour Party does not have an electoral man- date to introduce abortion. What the government is doing is proposing a sensible legislative intervention to address a situation that came to the fore last year, with the case of Andrea Prudente. The Prudente case was not the first of its kind, and certainly won't be the last. Countless other Maltese women have had to endure the trauma of an unviable pregnancy, and put through the unnecessary risk of developing potentially life-threatening complications, because they were never given the choice to safeguard their health and abort. But since then, there has been another defining case in this country's abortion debate. Only a fortnight ago, a woman in the most vulner- able of states was charged with performing a medical abortion and handed down a conditional discharge. It was only the court's compassionate understand- ing of the underlying circumstances that spared her a jail sentence. But the judgment also came with an admonishment that the woman should have sought help instead of choosing to terminate her pregnancy. Already a mother to a young child and living in an abusive relationship, this woman, who also suffers from mental health problems, chose to terminate a pregnancy she felt would have brought more compli- cations to her life and that of her young child. Indeed, she was reported to the police by her partner and having no choice, the police went on to prosecute. This case, which is rare but not unique, has chal- lenged the argument that, despite Malta's tough law, no woman has ever been charged over abortion. We now know it is a lie. Faced with this situation, the Prime Minister ex- pressed his own discomfort with the fact that a wom- an had to be criminally charged in court. But this newspaper today carries an open letter to the Prime Minister by gynaecologist Isabel Stabile, who writes on behalf of Doctors for Choice, in which she exhorts Abela to be more than 'uncomfortable' in front of this injustice; and to take the "bold step" of decriminalising abortion. Stabile is right. Like their European counterparts, women in Malta should have the right to choose whether to have an abortion without the fear of being reported, charged and possibly sent to jail. Already, hundreds of women every year either travel abroad – something financially inaccessible to the vulnerable – or buy pills online to self-medi- cate at home, with no comfort that they could seek non-judgemental medical aftercare in the case of complications. They do so in fear of being discovered. This leader endorses the position taken by Doctors for Choice and other pro-choice organisations calling for abortion to become legal. There is no place for abortion in the Criminal Code. Instead, it should be legislated for within the Health Act, with the neces- sary caveats to prevent a free-for-all. While fully recognising the government's attempt to bring some sanity to Malta's strict anti-abortion law, this leader urges the Prime Minister to move beyond discomfort. Politicians cannot be 'uncomfort- ably numb' to the pain, fear and stigmatisation Mal- tese women must endure because abortion remains a criminal act. Abela should ensure that the proposed legal chang- es to the Criminal Code are enacted without delay, and not diluted to the extent of creating impractical barriers to access. But he must then take steps to propose a holistic change in Malta's abortion law, and outline how this can be achieved within the confines of a democratic process. 11 June 2013 MaltaToday Survey | Cost of living remains major concern A MaltaToday survey about the public's con- cerns indicates that the major one remains the cost of living, followed by utility costs. But com- pared to November of last year, the percentage of those concerned about the cost of living dropped by 16.5%. However concern for jobs increased by 8%. The MT survey also asked respondents about Malta's economic prospects, and the over- whelming majority are optimistic three months after a change in government. Three months after the election of a new government, the Maltese are largely optimistic about the economic prospects of their country, but nearly four out ten think that the country is still at risk of going down the same path as EU member states like Greece and Cyprus, which had to resort to a painful bailout after declaring themselves bankrupt. A survey carried out among 400 respondents between Monday and Thursday shows that 48% expect the economy to grow in the next months, while less than 13% expect it to con- tract. But 38% still think that Malta faces a high or moderate risk of bankruptcy. The survey comes in the wake of a number of positive assessments of the Maltese economy by credit agencies like Fitch, Moody's and the International Monetary Fund, all of which gave the economy a clean bill of health despite ex- pressing concern about the deteriorating fiscal position and increase in public debt. In the past weeks Malta also found itself facing an exces- sive budget procedure by the European Com- mission, which expects the country's deficit to surpass the 3% permissible mark. The climate of optimism is particularly strong among Labour voters in the last gen- eral election, 73% of whom expect economic growth in the next months. This optimism is not shared by Nationalist voters, of whom only 27% expect the economy to grow. Still, even among the latter, the majority expects the economy either to grow or to remain at the same levels of today. A substantial number of PN voters (27%) expect the economy to remain at its current levels. Quote of the Week "It has become apparent that unorthodox behaviour is becoming commonplace, resulting in children being exposed to an increased level of bullying at a very young age." Statement by the Union of Professional Educators calling for the introduction of hand- held security scanners at schools to prevent students from concealing "threatening items" MaltaToday 10 years ago