Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1501675
maltatoday | SUNDAY • 18 JUNE 2023 11 LAW CLASSIFIEDS THE changes in circumstances may allow a change in legitimate expectations. This was held by the Court of Appeal, presided over by the Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti on 14 June 2023 in Michael Parnis et vs L-Awtorita ta' l-Ippjanar. The appeal was from a Planning and Environment Review Tribunal decision. The Court quoted from the Tribunal's decision, which re- fused the issuing of a development permit on a garden of a Palazzo in Ghaxaq. The Planning Authority had originally rejected the applica- tion, since the proposed develop- ment was in a schedule property and was deemed to be excessive. The appeal before the Tribunal concentrated on two grounds of appeal. The first ground of appeal pointed out that the Planning Au- thority (PA) ignored an outline permit that allowed construction in that site and therefore created a legitimate expectation. The ap- pellant held that the fact that the property is scheduled does not mean that no development can take place. The appellants also ar- gued that the changes in the plans were intended to address concerns the PA had on the development. The Appellants also pointed out that their application was being treated differently from other de- velopments, so much so that there are windows overlooking their property, since developments on the adjacent properties were al- lowed. The PA replied to the appeal be- fore the Tribunal stating that the outline permit was granted with a number of conditions. The PA held that although amendments were made to the plans, the pro- posed development was still seen as having a negative impact on the scheduled property. Flimkien Ghal Ambjent Ahjar, and the Ghaxaq local council reg- istered themselves as objectors and participated in the Tribunal's proceedings. The Tribunal in its decision dis- cussed the grounds of appeal on whether the outline permit gave the appellant a legitimate expecta- tion that the development permit should be issued. The Tribunal pointed out that the outline per- mit did not quantify the number of units permitted. The outline permit was issued in 2011 after the Appeal Board had listed a number of conditions including that the development should not be more than 30 residential units over three floors. The Tribunal reasoned that the planning laws and process is dy- namic and evolves in the interest of society. The Tribunal quoted from a Court of Appeal judgment Richard Tua vs L-Awtorità ta' Malta on 27 November 2014. The Court held that a develop- ment application is precisely that an application to carry out a devel- opment according to the policies applicable at the time of the ap- plication. Therefore, the applicant does not have any prior rights and the applicant is judged on the cur- rent law and policies. Therefore, the PA was bound to take into consideration not only the outline permit, but also the fact that the property was a sched- uled property and that there were a large number of objectors. The proposed development was on a garden of a Palazzo. The proposal included excavation of the garden, which was not included in the out- line permit. The PA considered this as excessive and was to disturb a number of features in the garden. As to the grounds of appeal that this application was being treated differently from other applica- tions in the vicinity, the Appellants made reference to another per- mit issued for development that took place on another part of the same garden of the Palazzo. The Tribunal held that the appeal was on the rejection of the application and not on the scheduling of the property. The scheduled property was lim- ited to the Palazzo and the garden and not to adjacent properties. The development referred to by the Appellant was not scheduled. The Court of Appeal in its judg- ment agreed with the Appellant that the outline permit allowed for a legitimate expectation. However, this was subject to what is called reserved matters that have to be taken into account when the full application was presented. The Board of Appeal allowed for not more than 30 residential units, divided into three blocks and not higher than three floors. Care had to be taken to the pave- ment and the development had to be receded. The Court of Appeal pointed out that following the out- line application the Palazzo and the garden were listed as a Grade 2 scheduled property. Therefore, the Court of Appeal is being asked whether the fact that the property is scheduled has any bearing on the outline application. Article 57(6) of the Development Planning Act states that the scheduling of the property should affect negative- ly development that has already taken place. In this particular case, there is no permit issued, but an expectation of a permit. The court turned down this ground of ap- peal. The Court of Appeal agreed with the Tribunal that although the Ap- pellants rights had to be respected, does not change the objectives of the outline application, principally the protection of the garden of the Palazzo. The PA emphasised on the features of the garden and that these should be respected in any development. The Court of Appeal moved to reject the appeal. Legitimate expectations are not set in stone LAW REPORT MALCOLM MIFSUD Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION MARSALFORN, Gozo - holiday apart- ments for short or long lets with mag- nificent sea-views. Call 21556021, 27556021, 79426883 PROPERTY TO LET SHOP TO LEASE - Class 4 B 60 sqm corner shop to lease in San Gwann. Key money €49,888 and €40 a day rental. Call on 79703404. XLENDI - catering premises in prime site to let. Can be used for other com- mercial purposes. Phone 79493021, 79426883, 77481592 or 77484029 SERVICES COLLECTIBLE items such panini albums and loose stickers, old postcards and posted envelopes, medals, militar- ia, coins and paper money, books, toys, stamps, badges, paintings, gold & silver items etc. Call on 21310238, 99246632. SITUATIONS VACANT CHEF - required for busy hotel res- taurant in Naxxar. Must be fluent in English, be able to work flexible hours including weekends and public holi- days. Min 3 years' experience in similar position. Call +365 2798 8357 for more info - The Village Hotel LTD. CLEANER - Godwin's Diamond Ice Ltd, in Gharghur is looking for a hard-work- ing person to work as a cleaner. If you are interested, please contact owner on 99492584s or email: sales@godwinsdia- mondice.com D.J.S TURNKEY SOLUTIONS LTD – we have the following vacancies: Cleaners (Construction Site) – Housekeepers – Maintenance Personnel – Plasters - Tile Layers - Brick layers – Delivery staff – Drivers – Electrician – Plumbers - Office Administrator. Candidates must have a minimum of 3 years' experience and good command of the English lan- guage. Interested personnel are to send their CV to dcdebono7969@gmail.com or by post to - D.J.S Turnkey Solutions Ltd 4, Emerald, Triq Pietru Xuereb, Hamrun. P L A ST E R E R AND GYPSUM INSTALLERS - Xuereb Installations Ltd of Tal-Hlas Road Qormi are seeking the immediate employment, on a full-time basis, of people skilled in plastering and in gypsum installations. The ideal candidate should be in possession of the appropriate qualifications related to gypsum assembly, construction works, plastering and painting. In the absence of qualifications, three years of expe- rience are required, in gypsum assem- bly, construction works, plastering and painting. A salary of €12,000 per annum is being offered to suitable candidates. Interested candidates are to send their cv by email to xil@xuerebinstall.com PL A ST E R E R S AND GYPSUM INSTALLERS - Pro Finishes Ltd of 131, Triq Tal-Franciz Swieqi, are seeking the immediate employment on a full- time basis, of persons skilled in plaster- ing and in gypsum installations. The ideal candidate should in possession of the appropriate qualification's rela- tion to gypsum assembly, construction works, plastering and painting. In the absence of qualifications, three years of experience are required, in gypsum assembly, construction works plastering and painting. A salary of €12000 per annum is being offered to the suitable candidates. Interested candidates are to send their CV by email to info@profin- ishesltd.com SECURITY GUARDS & CUSTOMER CARE - Kingdom Security Malta Ltd requires Security Guards & Customer Care officers. Applicants should be customer care orientated, smart and flexible for shift work. Kindly call on 21413777. CLASSIFIEDS INFO @MEDIATODAY.COM.MT VACANCY Job description Applicant will be expected to carry out duties in; - Maintaining house tidiness - Laundry & ironing - Cooking (is a bonus but not necessary), main- taining adequate food stock levels and writing shopping lists - Walking the dog occasionally - Caring for baby and helping with feeding and their needs Applicant must have prior experience in housekeeping and caring for children and be fluent in English, polite, trustworthy and professional please. Contact Kristina: 99859603