Issue link: https://maltatoday.uberflip.com/i/1508267
maltatoday | SUNDAY • 24 SEPTEMBER 2023 11 LAW CLASSIFIEDS LAW REPORT MALCOLM MIFSUD Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates THE Constitutional Court denies discharge as a provisional meas- ure. This was outlined in the re- cent judgment of Paul Demicoli vs the Attorney General et, decided by the Constitutional Court on 8 August 2023. This judgment illustrates the court's approach taken in granting interim measures. The plaintiff al- leged a violation of his right to a fair hearing within a reasonable time, as criminal proceedings persisted for 18 years. These proceedings commenced in 2004 and conclud- ed in 2022, with the accused being sentenced to two years' imprison- ment, 18 years after the commis- sion of the offence. Mr Demicoli, in his constitu- tional proceedings asserting such a violation due to the protracted duration of the proceedings, asked the Court to suspend the two-year imprisonment sentence until the final decision. He contended that should the Constitutional Court find a breach of his right to a trial within a reasonable time, it pos- sesses discretion to grant remedies that directly impact the punish- ment imposed by the Criminal Court. The Court of First Instance accepted this argument, and the First Hall of the Civil Court, in its constitutional capacity, ordered Mr Demicoli's release and the suspension of the two-year im- prisonment sentence until a final decision was reached. Addition- ally, the court imposed a deposit requirement of €5,000 and a per- sonal guarantee of €50,000. However, after obtaining special permission, the Attorney Gen- eral, the State Advocate, and the Commissioner of Police appealed the first court's decision. They as- serted that the initial court erred in granting such provisional meas- ures, as a prima facie violation of human rights had not been estab- lished, and that the interim meas- ures were not necessary to prevent irreparable harm. The Constitutional Court upheld the appeal, reasoning that interim measures should only be granted in exceptional circumstances. The appeal also highlighted that as a general rule, the decisions of oth- er courts should not be suspended solely on the basis of an allegation of a human rights violation. More- over, the appellate court was not convinced that a constitutional court would reduce Mr Demicoli's prison sentence. Provisional or "interim" meas- ures refer to court orders issued as interim remedies during the pendency of a Constitutional Case until its final decision. An example of an interim measure is when an individual facing the prospect of deportation to a country where they may encounter persecution or torture, asks the Constitutional Court to postpone the deportation pending the final decision deter- mining whether such deportation constitutes a violation of their hu- man rights. Interim measures are crucial, as there are instances when human rights transgressions can- not be adequately rectified once the infringement has taken place. Article 46 of the Constitution be- stows upon the Court the authori- ty to issue any orders, writs, or give any direction as it deems suitable to ensure the protection of human rights, as enshrined in Articles 33 to 45 of the Constitution of Mal- ta. The nature of human rights law necessitates that such cases are treated with urgency, in that violations of the most fundamen- tal rights are of the State's utmost concern as the State is positively obliged to protect and preserve the human rights of every individual. Interim measures do not prejudice the final decision of a court, and it may very well be the case of hav- ing a final decision which finds no breach of human rights notwith- standing the granting of a provi- sional remedy. One notable case in this regard is a judgment delivered by Judge Lorraine Schembri Orland (now serving as a judge at the Europe- an Court of Human Rights) in the names of Anthony Mario Vella et vs Registratur tal-Qrati Civili u Tribunali et. In this case, the plain- tiffs had been ordered by the Court of Appeal to vacate their residence in a proceeding initiated by HSBC Bank Malta PLC. The plaintiffs al- leged that they were denied a fair hearing in the eviction case, con- tending that they had not been af- forded a sufficient opportunity to respond to the Bank's claims. In its constitutional jurisdiction, the court as presided by Judge Schembri Orland, ordered the suspension of the eviction order issued by the Court of Appeal and held that nothing precludes the Constitutional Court from granting interim relief, even when such relief pertains to decisions rendered by other courts. Judge Lorraine Schembri Orland further elucidated that the Constitution often serves as the last recourse for citizens, and in certain instances, the sole safeguard against human rights infringements, irrespective of the validity of such actions un- der ordinary law. Mr Demicoli's judgment exem- plifies the Constitutional Court's approach to the issuance of pro- visional measures, which is pred- icated on the presence of an im- minent risk of irreparable harm. Local courts frequently invoke the writings and judgments of the Eu- ropean Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg to substantiate this ap- proach, effectively adopting a test necessitating the demonstration of peril to life or limb as a prereq- uisite for obtaining provisional measures. Additionally, Mr Demicoli's case highlights the Constitution- al Court's reluctance to step-in and suspend decisions rendered by other courts. Nevertheless, it is noteworthy that the law does not limit the Constitutional Court from taking such action, and there have been instances where the Constitutional Court has indeed suspended sentences imposed by other courts when a risk of irrepa- rable harm was identified. The Constitutional Court denies discharge as a provisional measure HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION MARSALFORN, Gozo - holiday apart- ments for short or long lets with mag- nificent sea-views. Call 21556021, 27556021, 79426883 PROPERTY TO LET SHOP TO LEASE - Class 4 B 60 sqm corner shop to lease in San Gwann. Key money €49,888 and €40 a day rental. Call on 79703404. XLENDI - catering premises in prime site to let. Can be used for other com- mercial purposes. Phone 79493021, 79426883, 77481592 or 77484029 SERVICES COLLECTIBLE items such panini albums and loose stickers, old postcards and posted envelopes, medals, militar- ia, coins and paper money, books, toys, stamps, badges, paintings, gold & silver items etc. Call on 21310238, 99246632. SITUATIONS VACANT CASHIER - Padthai Kitchen of Swieqi are seeking the immediate employment, on a FULL-TIME and PART-TIME basis of a person with knowledge of Thai cuisine to work as a cashier and to also assist in the general restaurant duties, for example explaining to customers the ingredients of dishes offered. Although no particular qualifications are required, the ideal candidate must be fluent in written and spoken Thai and English, must also demonstrate sound knowledge of Thai traditional and Thai cuisine. Experience in a similar position would be considered an asset. The candidate must also have a clean criminal record. The duties of the chosen candidate will include handling sales, assisting patrons with queries, helping as necessary in the restaurant (not cooking). The sala- ry of €5.50 per hour is being offered to the suitable candidate. Interested can- didates are to send their CV by email to padthaikitchen.malta@gmail.com with the words "Cashier" as subject by not later than Tuesday 10th October 2023. HR PLUS - requires labourers, cleaners, waiters, kitchen hands, drivers, plaster- ers, shop assistants, steel fixers, securi- ty guards, office clerks and carers. All vacancies are on a full-time basis, job entails being competent and responsi- ble. Lower secondary level of education is required and availability to work on weekends and public holidays. Interested parties are to apply by sending their CV to email: info@hrplusmalta.com MECHANIC - Oasis Operations Ltd are seeking mechanics. Kindly send your CV on philip@oasistoursmalta.com THAI STREET FOOD COOK – Padthai Kitchen of Swieqi is seeking the immedi- ate employment, on a full-time basis, of 2 Thai Street Food cooks. Their duties will include choosing the right ingredients on the market, food preparation, and cooking of authentic Thai Street food dishes. The ideal candidates should be in possession of the appropriate catering qualifications. In the absence of qualifi- cations, a minimum of five years' expe- rience is required, in a similar Thai res- taurant working as a cook. A salary of €10,800 per annum is being offered to the suitable candidates. Interested can- didates are to send their cv by email to padthaikitchen.malta@gmail.com with the words 'Thai Street Food Cook' by not later than Tuesday 10th October 2023. WAITER/WAITRESS - required for busy hotel restaurant in Naxxar. Must be fluent in English, be able to work flexi- ble hours including weekends and pub- lic holidays. Min 3 years' experience in similar position. Call +365 2798 8357 for more info - The Village Hotel LTD. CLASSIFIEDS INFO @MEDIATODAY.COM.MT